ScottJacob's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Breed - Nirvana cover]

Damn man, it's a pretty good cover your guitar work is impressive and vocals are very raw and passionate. I hide behind a computer when i make my music. To put yourself out there and put in that much effort in that performance is brave bro. Although it sounds very raw and rough, there is definitely some art to that. Good cover, to a great song man. Keep it up.

Stereocrisis responds:

Thank you. I don't care when people "hide behind a computer." That is another form of creating, and it takes a different kind of talent, but it ultimately achieves the same goal. I honestly only call people out for hiding behind a computer when they call me out for not using the latest technology to enhance my own sound. I have to just remind them, I'm not faking my love of lo-fi recordings. Some people, like me, prefer a raw sound to a slick sound. I feel some of the people who hear me do my thing think I'm not "doing it right" when instead, they don't realize, this is the sound I like. It's purposefully supposed to sound like a live version, because it is one.

[Caribbean Dream]

Good song, really well made. Though it's a little on the bright side EQing wise, it seems like you could cut some high end and add some more low end bass. Besides that man, it's got a catchy melody. Nice work!

JoshuaHughes responds:

Thank you! I've been thinking of some melodies in my head and figured out that one of them sounds a lot like this piece I made forever ago (it was published in 2013, but I made it like a year before that). I'm thinking I might revisit it and see if I can put a new spin on it.

[rover]

The guitar was pretty cool, it kind of felt like a Pink Floyd song for a moment. Enjoyable song, pretty good mixing job too nothing bad to speak of. Really good.

johnfn responds:

Yeah I love Pink Floyd, I'm sure I have some of their influence :D Thanks for the review!

[Break Through the Night]

Wow man! Feels like it's straight from the film's itself, how did you make this? Really remarkable song composition. I liked it all, the thunderous drums, whispering strings, all coming together to accompany the Dark Knight himself as he protects his beloved Gotham.

LunyAlex responds:

Thanks a lot man!
It's made using 3 sample libraries. Spitfire Albion (for Violins), Spitfire Albion Iceni (for Cellos) and Heavyocity Damage (for percussion).

I appreciate the kind words, they mean a lot.

[Global Elite]

Fun song indeed! I like the change of pace mid way it gives it a breath of fresh air. This would work great for a video game, i really like it man. Tis grand!

Mawnz responds:

Thank you! I was unsure about that part at first, but I guess the break was well needed :)
Thanks again for listening and reviewing!

[The White Fox]

It's a good song man, but idk maybe the speech sample could be buried a bit in the mix and turned down a bit, gets a little distracting. Maybe add some subtle reverb/delay. Drums could have been brought up a bit, snare sounded a bit flat. Maybe some eq could brighten it up a little, just as a tip. Though all in all not a bad song, i liked it. Keep it up

deadbea7 responds:

i agree with everything you said. this was literally my first attempt at using vocals. i've been working on a better version since i uploaded this. i was very aware of the shitty vocals, but i just couldn't figure out what i could do to fix it. but luckily you came along. i think turning it down or even removing a bit of it will help. thanks for your feedback, it's greatly appreciated for sure.

[DJ T3chnic - Reborn]

Nice work man! A very euphoric track, and altogether a very impressive effort. Like the last reviewer mentioned i liked how you kept things fresh by changing it up. Great sound mix, fast and fun, i enjoyed it very much.

DJT3chnic responds:

:) Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it.

[2k7]

Sounds like chiptune/video game song to me, which Newgrounds has a genre of that you can submit under.

i liked the song btw, the beats were cool. I liked the change in the middle, not sure about the end though it seemed a little out of place. The beginning got a little repetitive but i may just be being an asshole about it. It was an enjoyable song though, good stuff.

Qvarcos responds:

Hi, thanks for the review, appreciated!

I reupload it with a better ending, as i don't see that perfect either.

[First Deep One Sighting]

Hey Tonash, i thought the fact how someone else`s art inspired you to create your own dramatic composition was pretty cool. The effects along with all the music immersed the whole experience. The script was great, and you do possess the kind of voice to carry this kind of material. The whole ``light of the sun, is no more`` opening voice with the background wind was awesome work, though i think the dwarf voice over work was not as strong, and the accents got a bit messy. Overall i thought you did a great job the script and story was concise and the threat of battle was well communicated. Keep refining your voice over skills, good luck with this!

Tonash responds:

I agree that some of Gimble's lines got a little messy; albeit dwarfy accents are usually more rocky/grumbly than usual.

Thanks again.